Compare

TestOrchestrator vs Xray: a lighter alternative for teams without Jira-as-a-religion

Xray is a power tool for Jira-centric teams that need BDD, Cucumber, and deep traceability. TestOrchestrator is the lighter standalone option when the BDD+Jira complexity is overkill.

At a glance

Capability	TestOrchestrator	Xray
Hosting model	Standalone web app	Jira Cloud / Data Center app
Requires Jira	No	Yes
Pricing model	Flat monthly per workspace	Per Jira user, monthly
Free plan	Yes — 5 users	Free under 10 Jira users (Atlassian)
Manual test cases	First class	First class
BDD / Cucumber	Not first-class	First class
Exploratory testing	First class	Limited
Test case folders	Yes	Yes (folders + repositories)
Setup curve	Same day	Days for full BDD wiring

Pricing and feature claims about Xray change over time. Always confirm current Xray pricing and capabilities on the Atlassian Marketplace before deciding.

Where TestOrchestrator wins

Lighter footprint. No Jira install required, no BDD ceremony if your team doesn't write Gherkin.
Predictable cost. Flat monthly pricing instead of per-user — your bill doesn't track Jira headcount.
Exploratory testing built in. First-class sessions, charters, and logged findings — not a missing surface that has to be bolted on.
Faster onboarding. A new tester can be productive in an hour because there's only one UI to learn, not two (Jira + Xray).
No Jira-as-prerequisite. Useful when your test management vendor decision shouldn't depend on what your PM team uses.

Where Xray still wins

BDD-driven teams. If your engineers write Cucumber scenarios as the source of truth, Xray is built around that workflow with deep CI integration.
Test automation reporting. Xray's automated test result reporting (Cucumber, JUnit, NUnit, TestNG) into Jira is best-in-class.
Jira-coupled traceability. Requirements → tests → defects all in Jira issues, with mature dashboards.
Atlassian procurement. If your company buys everything via Atlassian Marketplace, adding to that contract is easier than introducing a new vendor.

Migrating from Xray

Sign up for a TestOrchestrator workspace at /signup.
For your existing cases:
- Small collection: create them directly in the test case repository — see the docs.
- Larger collection: export from Xray (REST API or built-in export) and contact support. We will load your cases into your workspace for you.
Configure Jira external references in External References so links to existing tickets keep working.
If you have BDD scenarios you want to keep, evaluate whether they belong as test cases in TestOrchestrator or stay as code in your repo with CI reporting.

A self-serve bulk-import UI is on the roadmap.

When to choose TestOrchestrator

You're a small-to-mid QA team that doesn't write Gherkin as the source of truth, you want flat predictable pricing, and your test management decision shouldn't be locked to Jira.

Start free or see pricing.

When to choose Xray

Your team is BDD-first, your CI emits Cucumber/JUnit results that feed Jira dashboards, and your stakeholders read those Jira dashboards. Xray earns its keep in that workflow.

Frequently asked questions

Is TestOrchestrator an Xray alternative?

Yes for teams who don't need Xray's BDD/Cucumber-first workflow or deep Jira coupling. TestOrchestrator covers the same core test management surface — repository, runs, exploratory sessions, reporting — without requiring Jira and without the BDD-centric data model.

Does TestOrchestrator support BDD or Cucumber feature files?

Not as a first-class data type. If your QA workflow is BDD-driven and you need to author and execute Gherkin scenarios as the primary artefact, Xray is the better fit. TestOrchestrator focuses on classic manual test cases, exploratory sessions, and release sign-off; deeper CI / framework integration is on the roadmap.

How does pricing compare?

Xray is per Jira user, monthly via Atlassian Marketplace. TestOrchestrator is flat monthly per workspace ($19 Starter / $79 Pro). Always check current Xray pricing on the Atlassian Marketplace.

Can I integrate TestOrchestrator with Jira?

Yes — link test cases and runs to Jira issues via external references without storing test data inside Jira.

When should I stay on Xray?

If your QA process is BDD-first, your engineers author Gherkin scenarios as the source of truth, and your CI runs Cucumber tests with Xray reporting back the results — Xray is built for that workflow and switching costs more than it saves.